Toilet Repair & Installation in Troy, Wentzville & St. Charles County
A wobbly, leaking, or constantly running toilet doesn’t just waste water it disrupts your whole day. Make the right choice by calling First Choice Heating, Cooling & Plumbing. We deliver fast, professional toilet repair and new toilet installation across Troy, Wentzville, O’Fallon, St. Peters, Lake St. Louis, Warrenton, Moscow Mills, Foristell, Wright City, and the surrounding areas of Lincoln, Warren, St. Charles, Pike, Montgomery, and St. Louis Counties.
Call or text 636-622-9200 for prompt, on-time service and clear, upfront pricing.

Why Homeowners Choose First Choice
When it comes to your home’s hot water system, you don’t want just anyone handling the job. Here’s why homeowners across the St. Louis metro area choose us
What We Service & Install
We repair and install all major brands and styles:
If you already purchased a toilet, we’ll install it professionally. Prefer a one-stop solution? We’ll source a vetted model, deliver it, and handle everything old unit disposal included.
Should I Repair or Replace My Toilet?
Here’s a quick guide:
Repair makes sense when:
- Your toilet is in good overall condition, under 12–15 years old, and parts are the issue
- You love the look/height and just need it to run right
- The problem is isolated (e.g., a flapper, fill valve, or wax ring)
Replace makes sense when:
- The toilet is old, stained, or hard to clean
- You want lower water bills with a WaterSense or dual-flush model
- It cracks, wobbles, or clogs often
- You’re remodeling and want a modern style or comfort height
Not sure? We’ll inspect and give you both options with clear pricing so you can choose what’s best for your home and budget.
Our Process (So Easy)
Water Efficiency & Performance Upgrades
Today’s toilets flush better with less water. Consider:
We’ll match your bathroom size, plumbing layout, and preferences to the right model.
Common Toilet Problems We Fix (Repair vs. Replace)
Toilets look simple, but several parts can fail. Here’s what we diagnose and fix every day:

1) Clogged or Slow-Flushing Toilet
If you plunge often or the bowl rises, gurgles, or drains slowly you may have:
Repair: Professional augering, camera inspection, or enzymatic treatments.
Replace: If the porcelain has hairline cracks or persistent clogs due to an outdated design, a modern high-efficiency model can solve it for good.
2) Constantly Running Toilet
That near-constant hiss usually means the fill valve, flush valve, or flapper isn’t sealing. Beyond the noise, a running toilet can waste hundreds of gallons a day.
Repair: Replace the worn component(s), adjust the chain, and set proper water level.
Replace: If the tank hardware is corroded throughout or the bowl/tank are cracked, replacement may be more cost-effective.

3) Leaking at the Base (Water on the Floor)
A dried-out wax ring seal or a loose/broken flange lets water escape with every flush. Left unchecked, you can get subfloor damage, odors, and mold.
Repair: Pull the toilet, replace the wax ring (or use an upgraded seal), correct flange height, and resecure with new bolts.
Replace: If your toilet is older, stained, or inefficient, this is a smart time to upgrade while the toilet is already pulled.
4) Wobbly or Rocking Toilet
Movement indicates a flange issue, loose bolts, or rotted flooring. Rocking accelerates leaks and can crack porcelain.
Repair: Shim and reseat properly, repair or reset the flange, and address any subfloor concerns.
Replace: If the toilet has stress cracks or you’re ready for a comfort-height/modern style, replacement is a win-win.
5) Cracked Tank or Bowl
Cracks are unsafe and often unrepairable. Even hairline cracks can suddenly worsen.
Replace: We’ll install a safe, efficient model to match your style and budget.
Financing Options
We understand that replacing a water heater isn’t always planned. That’s why we offer budget-friendly financing options to make your upgrade affordable. With flexible monthly payments, you don’t have to put off the comfort and reliability your family needs.
Join the Super Comfy Club
Want to avoid unexpected water heater problems? Our Super Comfy Club maintenance plan is the easiest way to keep your system running efficiently year-round.
Membership perks include:
For just $289/year, you’ll save money while protecting your home’s most important systems.
Service Areas
We’re proud to provide water heater repair and installation in Troy, Wentzville, Moscow Mills, Warrenton, O’Fallon, St. Charles, and throughout St. Louis County. Wherever you live in our service area,
First Choice is just a call away.
F.A.Q.
Frequently Asked Questions
It depends on the issue. Common repairs like a flapper, fill valve, or supply line are typically affordable; flange and wax-ring resets cost more because the toilet must be pulled and re-seated. We’ll diagnose and quote upfront so you can approve before any work begins.
Shut off the water and avoid using that toilet until we inspect it. Base leaks usually mean the wax ring failed or the flange is damaged/low. We’ll pull and reset the toilet with a new seal and correct flange height.
Yes, running toilets can waste hundreds of gallons per day. Often a simple flapper or fill-valve replacement solves it quickly and pays for itself in reduced water bills.
Loose bolts, a damaged flange, or subfloor issues. Rocking stresses the porcelain and can cause leaks. We’ll stabilize it properly and address any underlying causes.
